|
Adapted and excerpted from
Interpersonal Communication Handbook, (© 2004, Pearson Custom
Publishing, Boston, MA.) written by Wright State University’s Department of
Communication professors
B. Robinson and J. Alexander. |
Do you act like a doormat, or like a steamroller, or a doormat-with-spikes, or like
a pillar-of-stability in communicating with others? These are the
metaphors for the four interpersonal communication styles termed passive,
aggressive, passive-aggressive, and assertive. Check yourself
out against the Table below to see what your style is.
The word assertiveness is often confused with aggressiveness. In the
context of interpersonal communication, there is a fundamental
difference between the two. Aggressiveness is getting what you want without regard for
others. Assertiveness, on the other hand, means standing up for your own
rights with equal regard for rights of others. Passive people allow themselves to be taken advantage of and
disrespected by others. The passive-aggressive pretend to be
passive only to get you later. Did you figure out which style you are? Actually, most of us
use every one of the four communication styles at different times and
depending on the situation. Still, we tend to have one dominant style.
Interpersonal Communication Styles*
(click here for
bigger print)
|
Style
Dimensions |
Passiveness |
Aggressiveness |
Passive-Aggressiveness |
Assertiveness |
| Characteristics |
Others choose
for you.
Emotionally dishonest.
Self-effacing.
Self-denying. |
You choose for
others.
Inappropriately honest.
Direct, critical.
Self-aggrandizing. |
You choose for
others.
Emotionally dishonest>
Self-protecting
Indirect way of getting own way. (Guilt-trips.) |
You choose for self.
Appropriately honest.
Direct, self-respecting.
Self-expressing. |
| Metaphor |
Doormat |
Steamroller |
Doormat with
spikes |
Pillar |
| Belief System |
"I should never
make anyone upset." |
"No one should
make me upset." |
"I should never
let anyone know I'm upset." |
"Let's talk over what we're
upset about." |
| Verbal and
Nonverbal Behavior |
Moves back:
underreacts, silent, soft |
Moves forward:
overreacts, blames, accuses |
Moves around,
hides reaction, sarcastic, procrastinating |
Stands firm: acts,
uses "I" language |
| Response to
Conflict |
Avoids, gives
in |
Attacks
directly |
Attacks
indirectly |
Works for win-win solutions |
| Goal |
Protect self
from losing |
Win |
Prevent others
from winning |
Mutuality |
| Your Feelings
in the exchange |
Now: anxious,
ignored, helpless, manipulated.
Later: resentful |
Now:
self-righteous, superior, powerful.
Later: guilty, lonely |
Now:
self-righteous, in control.
Later: Misunderstood |
Now: confident,
self-respecting, goal oriented.
Later: accomplished |
| Others'
feelings in the exchange |
Superior,
guilty, frustrated |
Angry, afraid,
resentful, hurt |
Taken,
distrusting, mislead, angry |
Valued, respected |
| Others' view of
you in the exchange |
Wishy-washy
Insecure
Don't know where you stand |
Obnoxious,
pushy, controlling; Know and dread your stand |
Superficially
pleasant, but sneaky; Oppositional, Don't know where you
stand |
Honest, trustworthy
Confident
Know where you stand |
| Usual Outcome |
Others get what
they want at your expense.
Your rights are ignored. |
Get what you
want at others' expense.
Others' rights are ignored. |
Get what you
want, but at others' expense.
Both rights are unclear. |
You get what you want.
Your and others' rights are respected. |
|
*From: B. Robinson & J. Alexander, Interpersonal Communication Handbook,
© 2004, Pearson Custom Publishing, Boston, MA. |
Out of the four communication styles, assertiveness clearly stands out
as the best style for most of us most of the time. Why? Because
assertiveness is most conducive for good long-term relationships, most
synergy, most satisfaction, least guilt, most effectiveness, and most
mutual respect. One definition of assertiveness is that it is the
ability to share the full range of your thoughts and feelings with
confidence and skill without judging or dictating to others. Although
assertiveness is the best communication style most of the time, there
can be situations when the other styles may be more appropriate e.g. in
sports, certain business and diplomatic situations.
Techniques of Assertiveness:
|
"Be fair with
others, but then keep after them until they're fair with you." --
Alan Alda |
There are three main techniques of
assertiveness:
-
Broken Record: Calmly repeating what you want or don’t want, over and
over again, demonstrates persistence without upset or defensiveness.
Example Dialog:
Salesman: “Would you like to buy this encyclopedia?”
You: “Thank you but I am not interested.”
Salesman: “Your children will love it.”
You: “I am not interested.”
Salesman: “Sir, it is a great bargain.”
You: “I am not interested.”
Salesman: “Don’t you care about saving time and money?”
You: “Thank you. I am not interested.”
-
Fogging: Acceptance of manipulative criticism by calmly acknowledging
to your critic the probability that there may be some truth in what s/he
says, yet allows you to be the judge of what you do.
Example:
Child: “You just don’t care about me. All the other
children have video iPods.”
You: “You’re right. I don’t care.”
-
Negative Inquiry: Active prompting of criticism in order to use the
information (if helpful) or exhaust it (if manipulative) while
encouraging your critic to be more assertive and say what s/he thinks.
Example:
Employee to boss: “Is there something I should have done
to deserve
a promotion?”
Assertive Format: Assertive format involves the “I” language (as opposed
to “you” language) that uses as objective descriptions as possible,
along with one’s own emotions and desires. For example, saying “I feel
upset because I find the work not done on time” as opposed to “you make
me upset because you don’t do work on time.”
Assertive Rights and Responsibilities:
It is important to recognize that the rights and responsibilities go
together to be considered assertive. The rights without responsibilities
become aggressive. Thus together, they are:
|
Assertive Rights and Responsibilities** |
| Rights |
Responsibilities |
You have the right to:
1. Be the judge of your own behavior
2. To express your beliefs and feelings
[use "I" language statements]
3. To ask for respect
4. To give self credit
[Don't be self-effacing]
5. Say: "I don't know"
"I don't understand"
"I can't help you"
"I don't care"
"No!"
6. Change your mind with more information
7. make mistakes [but own them]
8. Offer no justification
9. Be disliked
10. Decide not to be assertive |
You have the responsibility to:
To allow others differernt opinions
To be constructive
[be specific]
To give respect [to others]
To give others credit
To be sensitive to others
To explain the changes to people who
are affected by the change
To allow others to make mistakes
To deal with the consequences
of your behavior
To listen to others
To be flexible |
|
**From: B. Robinson & J. Alexander, Interpersonal Communication Handbook,
© 2004, Pearson Custom Publishing, Boston, MA. |
Books For Further Reading:
-
"The Complete Idiot's Guide to Assertiveness"
by Jeff Davidson
-
"Your Perfect Right: Assertiveness and
Equality in Your Life and Relationships," by Robert E.
Alberti and Michael L. Emmons.
-
"When I say No, I Feel Guilt," by Manuel J.
Smith
Updated: 18 Nov
2005
|