Back to Newsletter Home Page
WAC Newsletter
Number 14
Wright State University
May 1999
IN THIS ISSUE:
Using Note Cards and Journals to Grapple with Course
Material
May CTL Workshops
Review of The Journal Book
Tips from Other Programs
Library Term Paper Clinics
WAC News Around Campus
WAC Workshop
Using Note Cards and
Journals to
Grapple with Course Material
May 1999
| Dr. Anne Sisson Runyan (Political Science, Director of Women's
Studies) has been employing two methods of informal writing in her
political science and women's studies courses that she finds effective.
She has asked students to keep note cards on hand on which they can pose
questions that arise as they read, and she's had them write more lengthy
journal assignments that require them to engage the course material from
several different perspectives.
Since Dr. Runyan doesn't usually assign formal grades to these kinds of writing assignments, students are afforded opportunities to engage the text and course materials less formally and more freely than they are typically able to do with the more extensive writing projects she assigns, such as term papers. Note Cards Note cards count for points and are graded for content and ideas, not for grammar. She finds that providing students with opportunities to really grapple with and question what they're encountering-as they encounter it-can often help students think and write more critically. |
| Having students pose questions on note cards as they read can facilitate several processes. Asking for questions each week requires students to keep up with the readings and provides topics for classroom discussions. The questions allow Dr. Runyan to see what students are getting from the text and what they're not. She responds briefly to the students individually, but she can also get a sense of what kinds of things are difficult for the class in general. "Students ask you questions," she says, and they "tell you where they are in the course." | When students must formulate intelligent questions about what they're reading, it requires not only that they read, but that they read with focus. |
| When students must formulate intelligent questions about what they're reading, it requires not only that they read, but that they read with focus. Dr. Runyan finds that this practice helps students with something that is not always easy for them: reading critically and questioning the text. The note cards challenge them to do both, and since they have little room to write, they must also practice brevity and conciseness-practices that don't always show up in other kinds of course work. |
| Journal Writing
Dr. Runyan has recently been using another kind of informal writing to get students thinking more deeply about the course material. She has required journal writing assignments that again allow students room to explore topics outside the formality of a term paper, but at the same time she requires that they think deeply about issues and apply them to a larger context. These assignments are generally two to three pages long and must be completed weekly, although Dr. Runyan may collect them only every few weeks at a staggered rate to ease the burden of responding to a class of 25-30 students. |
| Journal assignments encompass a variety of tasks as a way of getting students to tap into different strengths and skills. She challenges them to think beyond the surface level of what they encounter and apply course material to other situations, to "think synthetically about things they've learned." | Dr. Runyan intends to challenge students to "integrate their own opinion with informed understanding" of the issues, to create an environment where they can't simply be "passive observers. |
Below are some examples of what students might be asked to do for
journal assignments. These are general descriptions rather than the more
discipline specific and detailed instructions she gives to her students.
They demonstrate the various ways in which students must process the
course material.
These assignments get students to practice writing-and thus thinking-from different perspectives. The journal writing allows them the freedom to grapple with their ideas, to grasp concepts and try to express them on the page. Dr. Runyan intends for these journal assignments to go beyond personal reflection and instead push students to consider how the readings and course material affect their own views. In essence, she hopes that this forum for student writing challenges them to "integrate their own opinion with informed understanding" of the topics and issues. Dr. Runyan also notes that the kinds of writing described here can easily be adapted for use in the classroom. Students may pause to pose questions before beginning a class discussion. Journal writing may be performed quickly in class when students are often most actively engaged in discussion of the topics. Students may work in pairs to discuss a problem or question for a few minutes before then writing about it. What Dr. Runyan intends is to promote an environment in which students "can't be passive observers," an environment that encourages students to think and write critically about what they're learning. -Scott Geisel |
| The Center for Teaching and Learning (CTL) is offering the following
workshops during May. Faculty attending the CTL CORE CURRICULUM
offerings (Instructional Design and Applications and Writing Across the
Curriculum programs are included) may request documentation of their
participation for merit or promotion and tenure purposes. Upon
completion of offerings from three of the five CORE CURRICULUM modules,
faculty may also receive a Teaching Enhancement Certificate (TEC) for
the current academic year.
To register or to obtain more information about any of these
workshops, call the CTL at x3162. You can also register on the CTL
Web page. COURSE DESIGN Distributed Learning (Luncheon). Led by George Frey, Associate
Director, CTL. Tuesday, May 25, 11:00 a.m.-1:00 p.m. in 104 Television
Center. PRESENTATION MODES: Improving Classroom Teaching Changing College Classrooms (Book Group Luncheon). Led by Virginia Nehring, Associate Professor, Nursing. Call x3162 to make your reservation and to receive your complimentary copy of Diane Halpern's Changing College Classrooms. Tuesday, May 11, 11:00 a.m.-1:00 p.m. in E156A Student Union. Teaching to Types: Applying Type Theory in Your Classroom
(Luncheon). Led by Richard Baker, Department of Aerospace Studies, and
Terri Limbert, University Division. Tuesday, May 18, 11:00 a.m.-1:00
p.m. in E156B Student Union. POLICY ISSUES How to Address Issues of Academic Dishonesty (Luncheon). Led
by Gary Dickstein, Assistant Director for Judicial Affairs, Residence
Services, and Robert Adams, Associate Professor, Political Science.
Thursday, May 27, 11:00 a.m.-1:00 p.m. in E156A Student Union. INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN AND APPLICATIONS WORKSHOPS (IDA) Introduction to PowerPoint (WIN) Friday, May 14, 10:00 a.m.-12:00 noon. Led by Dara Bornstein-Tudor, Multimedia Consultant, CTL. Advanced Features with Astound (WIN) Wednesday, May 19, 2:00-4:00 p.m. Led by Terri Klaus, Associate Director, CTL. Graphics and Information Design 101: Creating Effective and Engaging Presentations Friday, May 28, 10:00 a.m.-12:00 noon. Led by Denise Tanka, Senior Produce/Director, CTL, and Bruce Stiver, Supervisor, Graphics Production and Photography, CTL (A comfortable, working knowledge of PowerPoint or similar presentation software required.) |
| The Journal Book: For Teachers in Technical and Professional Programs, ed. Susan Gardner and Toby Fulwiler (Portsmouth: Boynton/Cook-Heinemann, 1999) ISBN: 0-86709-453-2 |
| The value of using journals as a means of learning has long been recognized. In this issue of the newsletter, Ann Sisson Runyan describes ways she uses journals in some of her classes, and the two previous issues also included articles by Wright State University faculty about ways they have employed journals. The publication of the present volume early this year attests to continuing interest in the topic. |
| The new book might be seen as something of a sequel to The
Journal Book, a collection of essays edited by Toby Fulwiler. Since
its publication by Boynton/Cook-Heinemann in 1987, The Journal Book
has been an important resource for faculty in many disciplines who wish
to use informal, expressive writing as a way to help their students
learn. As one of the first books on the topic, it covered as much of the
field as possible. The first group of essays outlined some of the values
of keeping journals, mixing pedagogical theory and first-person
testimonials to justify the practice. The next section was devoted to
the use of journals in a variety of English classes. Parts 3 and 4 took
up journal writing in the arts, humanities, and "quantitative
disciplines."
Among the fields covered were history, music, philosophy, foreign language, physics, mathematics, sociology, political science, and economic geography. The coverage of class levels ranged from elementary through college, taking in middle school and high school along the way. This new volume is considerably slimmer. It is much more narrowly focused, dealing only with technical and professional programs at the college level. Among the topics now covered are engineering and computer science, teacher training, and preparation for various medical and legal professions (see sidebar for complete listing of contents). A number of the selections deal with using electronic journals, a possibility not widely available when the first Journal Book was published a dozen years ago. Despite the range of academic subjects covered, the essays have a good deal in common. The first twelve essays are practice oriented, concentrating on the immediate utility of journals for students and teachers alike and referring readers to other sources for supporting pedagogical theory. Most draw heavily on student journals to provide evidence of the level of critical thinking students engage in. Several writers describe failed journal assignments and subsequent modifications; a number include the directions they provide for students. These illustrations, together with the detailed discussion of the aims of the various assignments, make it easy to see the ways particular strategies might be adapted in other academic fields. The discussion of ways journals promote problem solving for computer science students, for instance, has implications for classes in most other fields. Likewise, the solutions provided for the problems of evaluating journals can easily cross most disciplinary boundaries. The final essay takes a different direction from the rest, turning from specific practices and assignments to the issue of evaluation in a larger sense, considering the kinds of assessment that might go on with journals. In fact, the two questions posed by Kathleen Blake Yancey and Brian Huot ought to underlie all assessment, not just the assessment of student journals: "(1) What do we value in student work? and (2) How can we communicate what we value to students so as to enhance their learning?" (162). No simple answers are forthcoming, of course, but the discussion that follows should challenge readers to examine their own expectations of students and their responses to student writing. The collection concludes with a pair of brief but extremely useful supplements by the editors: "Setting Up Successful Journals," Gardner's highly practical set of tips for getting started, and "When Journals Don't Work," Fulwiler's suggestions for dealing with the difficulties most commonly identified in connection with journals. The latter section includes at least one surprise. |
CONTENTS 1. "Journals in Medical Education: Experience of a First-Year Class," Janet Ashbury, Barbara Fletcher, and Rick Birtwhistle 2. "Connecting Classroom and Clinical Experience: Journal Writing in Nursing," Ann Dobie and Gail Poirrier 3. "Developing a Professional Identity with Journal Reading and Writing: The Advanced Composition Course for Nursing, Social Work, and Pharmacy Students," Sandra J. Balkema 4. "Encouraging Active Learning: Adding a Journal to Engineering Lecture Courses," Douglas E. Hirt 5. "Designing Conversations: The Journal in an Engineering Design Class," Joel Greenstein and Beth Daniell 6. "Using Journals in Compute Science Courses: Helping Students Connect," Bobbie Othmer and Terry Scott 7. "Electronic Journals: Encouraging Reflection in Preservice Teachers," MaryEllen Vogt and Keith Vogt 8. "Writing Letters Instead of Journals in a Teacher-Education Course," Jane Danielewicz 9. "TechJournals: Electronic Journal Keeping for the Technical Writing Classroom," Gian Pagnucci 10. "Traditional or Electronic: Using Dialogue Journals for the First Time in Accounting Classes," Alan Rogers and Jerry VanOs 11. "Confronting Issues: Criminal Justice Students and Journal Writing," Michelle Heward and Gary Dohrer 12. "Distinguishing Between Fact and Opinion: Journals in a Legal Assistant Program," Kelly De Hill 13. "Assessing Journals in the Disciplines: An Inductive Inquiry," Kathleen Blake Yancey and Brian Huot |
| After recommending several ways to prevent students from writing all
the entries the night before the journal is due, Fulwiler says that the
idea that students are "faking it" no longer angers him
because even "faking it" may still achieve some of the
instructor's goals. He reached that conclusion after watching his own
daughter spend "hours and hours fabricating journal entries"
that looked as if they had been written over the course of the term:
"She reread chapters, looked up passages, copied in quotes,
invented questions, created connections, speculated and wondered,
arranging each entry in a plausible chronological order" (169).
Perhaps not everyone will be as optimistic as Fulwiler on that particular point. However, anyone wishing to investigate some beneficial ways of employing journal writing to help students learn in technical and professional fields should find much of use here. -Joe Law |
Tips from Other
Programs
University of Hawaii at Manoa
May 1999
| Suggestions from the Manoa Writing Program (MWP) have been featured in other newsletters. Here are two more that may prove useful. |
| It's a fairly common complaint that student papers don't really
respond to the assignment given--no matter how carefully we have written
and explained that assignment. Questions usually won't arise until
later, when students are actually attempting to write. To help discover
those questions and misunderstandings earlier, the MWP suggests the
following informal writing activity: "On the day an assignment is
handed out, ask students to turn the assignment sheet over and write a
three or four sentence paraphrase of it on the back. Several students
can read them aloud, and then the class can discuss the degree to which
these paraphrases accurately reflect the work they've been asked to
perform. It's an exercise that helps many students." For details on
this writing activity and other informal ways to stimulate thinking, see
http://
www2.hawaii.edu/uhmwrite/resource/informal.htm.
The other suggestion concerns students' seeming failure to see connections between their various writing activities. Knowledge and skills addressed in previous assignments are left behind, with the new task approached as a totally new activity. The MWP points out that research in psychology shows that human beings are "situation-specific" learners, often seeing connections between and across situations only when they're pointed out. Student self-assessments can be used to help students see those connections. For instance, students may be asked to find concepts or ideas that connect different assignments. They might also be directed to reflect on what they have done in completing previous assignments, determine what has (or hasn't) worked, and describe how those strategies can be applied in the current situation. The full text of this discussion is available online at http://www.hawaii.edu/uhmwrite/wi/writmat5.htm. |
Library Term Paper
Research Clinics
May 1999
| They're going fast! For two more weeks the Dunbar Library will be
offering Term Paper Research Clinics. These Clinics give students the
opportunity to identify resources and strategies for research
assignments in any discipline. Students meet one-on-one with a librarian
for a half-hour appointment. Clinics for Spring Quarter are available
until May 21. Students should come to the Information Desk at the Dunbar
Library to reserve an appointment. Please direct any questions about the
Term Paper Research Clinics or requests for additional course-related
research instruction to Doug Kaylor at 775-3142 or doug.kaylor@wright.edu.
PLEASE NOTE: You are strongly encouraged to refer your students to the Clinics; however, please refrain from making the Clinics a required class assignment When students participate voluntarily, the one-on-one sessions can be very effective, but they are much less effective when the Clinics are a compulsory assignment. |
Beyond the Term Paper Research Clinic
| The Wright State University Libraries' online "Subject Guides to Information" are available all the time to point your students to electronic and print resources for each subject area. Included in the Guides are recommended websites and research guides for some subtopics. Please encourage your students to check them out at http://www.libraries.wright.edu/libnet/subj/. If you are interested in additional websites to support a particular course or project, please contact your subject librarian. A list of all the subject librarians and their contact information is available at http://www.libraries.wright.edu/staff/ central/cnis/outreach.html. |
WAC-Related News from
Around the Campus
May 1999
| WSU Faculty to Present at WAC Conference
Three faculty members will represent Wright State at the Fourth Annual Writing Across the Curriculum Conference at Cornell University. Rebecca Berens Koop (Management Science and Information Systems), Michele Turner (College of Nursing and Health), and Joe Law (WAC Coordinator, English Dept.) will travel to Ithaca, New York, for the national conference held June 3 - 5. The three will present a panel discussion titled Connecting WAC and Discursive Skills in Specific Disciplines: Three Approaches at Wright State University. Joe Law will present "Breaking the Codes, Breaking the Boundaries: Using 'Great Books' to Foster Critical Thinking Skills in Other Disciplines," describing how a general education course can introduce students to the idea of writing in other disciplines. Rebecca Berens Koop's "Getting Top Billing: Linking Writing to Technical Success for Management Information Systems" discusses means of demonstrating to students how a series of writing assignments has practical value in developing a project. Michele Turner explores how writing that develops critical thinking helps prepare nurses for work in the field in "Developing Critical Thinking Levels Required for Nursing Practice." |
ROTC Students' Writing Published
The September 1998 issue of the WAC Newsletter highlighted an assignment that Lt. Colonel Adrienne Campbell (Air Force ROTC) uses in her Aerospace Studies 200 course. Two of Lt. Colonel Campbell's students have turned the autobiographical pieces that they wrote for that assignment into published work in Leader: The Air Force ROTC Information Source. Cadet Matthew Human's reflections on travelling to Mexico to help build a house for a homeless family was published as "A Family in Need" in February 1999. In the December 1998 issue, cadet Jenner Torrence's essay explores personal motivations and ambitions in "Cadet Shares Passion for Flying." Colonel Campbell's assignment is available on this Web site.
At the beginning of the spring quarter, the WAC coordinator's office moved to 027 Dunbar Library. This is just around the corner from the previous location. You can now find Joe Law right next to the tunnel entrance to the Library. All of the resources of the WAC office are still available to faculty. Contact Joe Law (x2155) if you're interested in looking at handbooks, texts, back issues of newsletters, or other teaching tools. |
| The final WAC workshop for the spring quarter will be presented during
the second week of May. To register for a workshop, you may call Joe Law
at x2155 or e-mail him at joe.law@wright.edu.
Workshops are open to all instructors interested in using writing in
their classes, not just those teaching designated writing intensive
classes.
Workshops will be offered twice to accommodate different teaching schedules. All begin at noon and last about an hour. A light lunch will be provided. Outcome-Based Learning and WAC Wednesday, May 12, 12:00 noon-1:00 p.m. Increasingly, faculty in higher education have been discussing-and planning-their teaching in terms of learning outcomes. At Wright State, for example, the revised General Education program calls for each area of the program to identify its desired learning outcomes, and many agencies require programs or majors to identify a coherent set of learning outcomes as part of the accrediting process. This session will provide an opportunity to discuss ways that writing might figure in learning outcomes for individual classes, both to achieve and to assess learning within the class. |
This page posted May 10, 1999.
Send comments to Dr. Joe Law